An analysis of the review of the current theories of dualism and materialism

The first group includes identity theory, philosophical behaviorism and eliminativism; the second group includes property dualism and functionalism. He believed the mind can literally assume any form being contemplated or experienced, and it was unique in its ability to become a blank slate, having no essential form.

The soul is the substantial form and so the first actuality of a material organic body with the potentiality for life. For example, the hunger is a state of the mind while the feeling of pain is another state. I leave it to the reader to draw the implications.

According to non-reductive physicalism all mental states are causally reducible to physical states where mental properties map to physical properties and vice versa. The mechanism which explains the connection between the mental and the physical would therefore be a philosophical proposition as compared to a scientific theory.

Rene Descartes The question that the dualists had to deal with was if these two elements can affect each other.

Mind–body dualism

The above point can be extended. The popular alternative to dualism is monism, the view that only material substances and properties exist. This concept of the human mind is called monism. Now, if the adult has this soul, at what point did he acquire it.

Hobbes would have to attribute it to an unconscious motivation in order to reconcile his theories, but the unconscious might as well be a soul. Patricia and Paul Churchland argued that folk psychology will be gradually replaced as neuroscience matures. This of course is only a bare outline of volitional dualism, and therefore suffers from vaguenesses of its own.

There is no question of degree here. The view may be contrasted with that of the earlier philosopher Anaxagoraswho thought that when, for example, the bread that a person eats is transformed into human flesh, this must occur because bread itself already contains hidden within itself the characteristics of flesh.

Bibliography Brenner, William H. The difference between a person who knows all about the visual cortex but has never enjoyed the sensation-of-red, and a person who knows no neuroscience but knows well the sensation-of-red, may reside not in what is respectively known by each brain states by the former, nonphysical qualia by the latter but rather in the different type, or medium, or level of representation each has of the same thing: One further objection to the identity theory runs along these lines: But substance dualism as formulated by Descartes fails to make certain important distinctions, and because of this vagueness, Cartesian dualism seems to classify as mental certain processes that are more properly classified as functional or even material.

Thus, if given an eternity in which to do so, it will, necessarily, exercise that potential. I will also consider counterarguments to dualism at the end of this essay. Against the objection that a purely physical process a dance of electrons, protons, and so on cannot have the sensory quality of greenness that is observed in a visual experience of seeing grass, say, they replied that to talk of the sensory experience of something looking green or having a green mental image is not to talk of anything that is literally green, but is simply to report that some internal process is of the sort that normally goes with seeing something, such as a lawn, which really is green.

The natural process of Goal-directedness begins with the sensation of the events in our environment. Nevertheless, the problems of mechanizing intelligenceincluding the mathematical abilities of human beings, do pose unsolved problems that the materialist is obliged to take seriously.

But philosophers have not been able to agree on a formulation of the materialist position. German philosophers derided idealism and taught the equivalence of consciousness and chemistry: Regardless of how much credence introspective evidence merits for scientific purposes, the very fact that introspection occurs at all is a blow to the materialist position.

In his letter to Elisabeth of Bohemia, Princess Palatinehe suggested that spirits interacted with the body through the pineal glanda small gland in the centre of the brainbetween the two hemispheres.

Imagine the case of a person, Frederick, who has a counterpart born from the same egg and a slightly genetically modified sperm. Also, everyone has had the experience of making a mistake in reasoning that seems absolutely plausible at the time but is later shown to be false.

But I think it suffices to show that, if suitably developed, volitional dualism could be an alternative to both materialism and Cartesian dualism. The theory denies that immaterial or apparently immaterial things such as minds exist or else explains them away as being material things or motions of material things.

The self is the locus of experience, i.


Behaviorism and central-state theories derived from the reductive materialism when the sensations, feelings, etc. Evolutionary theory as it is currently formulated is a diachronic study of material processes.

For instance, humans act in ways that cannot be readily explained by physical, observable principles. On the whole, materialism is contrary to the spirit of both Indian and traditional Chinese philosophythough the Carvaka school of materialists flourished from the 6th century bce until medieval times in India.

Although Mary knows everything there is to know about colours from an objective, third-person perspective, she has never known, according to Jackson, what it was like to see red, orange, or green. Substance dualism is not among the most popular theories of mind in contemporary philosophy.

Although, a number of significant contemporary philosophers maintain that property dualism 1 or substance dualism 2 is true. In each person there is a dualism according to this philosophy. This is the dualism of mind and body. There is a common expression which speaks of "mind over matter" which assumes this dualism.

The Philosophy of Mind

But a problem arises when trying to explain how the two substances can interact. Materialism: Materialism, in philosophy, the view that all facts (including facts about the human mind and will and the course of human history) are causally dependent upon physical processes, or even reducible to them.

The word materialism has been used in modern times to refer to a family of metaphysical. TEST 3. STUDY. PLAY. What is the connection (if any) between the mind and the body (or brain)? Five popular theories: +Dualism +Materialism +Behaviorism +Functionalism +Computer View.

Theory #1: Dualism. Ignorance of current scientific research and findings Math phobia Skepticism or incredulity of scientific findings.

Online Articles

Volitional dualism is a reformulation of substance dualism that takes both the explanatory successes and failures of materialism into account. Such a reformulation emphasizes the importance of consciousness, rather than information processing, as an object of philosophical understanding.


CONCEPTUAL ANALYSIS, DUALISM AND THE EXPLANATORY GAP. Final Version (revised August, ) Forthcoming in The Philosophical Review. by Ned Block and Robert Stalnaker. 1. Introduction. One point of view on consciousness is constituted by two claims.

An analysis of the review of the current theories of dualism and materialism
Rated 4/5 based on 63 review
Dualism versus Materialism |